Medically reviewed by Mufaddal M. Gombera, MD, Board-Certified Orthopedic Surgeon.
Dr. Mufaddal Gombera tore his own ACL playing football at Memorial High School in Houston, and that injury is the reason he became a sports medicine surgeon. He is board-certified in orthopedic surgery with subspecialty certification in sports medicine, and he treats ACL injuries at every level, from high school athletes to active adults. If your knee popped, swelled within hours, and no longer feels trustworthy, this page explains what happened and what to do about it.
What Is an ACL Tear?
The anterior cruciate ligament, or ACL, is one of two ligaments that cross in the center of the knee, connecting the thighbone (femur) to the shinbone (tibia). It stops the shinbone from sliding forward and controls rotation. A tear happens when the ligament is stretched past its limit, usually during a cut, a pivot, or an awkward landing. Most ACL tears happen without any contact at all.
The Pop, the Swelling, the Instability
Most ACL tears announce themselves in three steps. First, a pop you hear or feel at the moment of injury. Second, swelling that arrives within the first two hours, caused by bleeding inside the joint. Third, instability: a buckling or giving-way sensation whenever the knee twists or changes direction.
Not every tear follows the script. Some people finish the game and only notice the problem the next day. If your knee swelled quickly after a twisting injury, treat it as an ACL tear until proven otherwise.
Partial vs Complete Tears
A partial tear leaves some ligament fibers intact; a complete tear leaves none doing their job. The distinction matters because a partial tear that keeps the knee stable can often be rehabilitated without surgery. A complete tear cannot heal itself, so the decision becomes whether your life demands a stable, reconstructed knee. An exam and MRI together tell Dr. Gombera which situation you are in.
Discover Your Ortho Options
Who Needs Reconstruction, and Who Does Not
Not every torn ACL needs surgery, and Dr. Gombera will tell you directly which side of the line you are on.
Reconstruction usually makes sense for:
- Athletes in pivoting and cutting sports such as football, soccer, and basketball
- People whose work involves climbing, jumping, or uneven ground
- Anyone whose knee gives way during everyday activities
- Patients with a repairable meniscus tear alongside the ACL injury
Rehabilitation without surgery is a legitimate choice for:
- Lower-demand or older patients whose knees stay stable in daily life
- People who stick to straight-line activities such as cycling, swimming, or jogging
- Patients willing to modify activities and commit to a strengthening program
For that second group, ACL reconstruction adds surgical risk without a clear benefit. A functional brace can add support during the transition.
Why Untreated Instability Damages the Knee Over Time
An unstable knee feels untrustworthy, and each giving-way episode grinds away at structures you cannot regrow. Each giving-way episode can pinch and tear the meniscus and scuff the articular cartilage, the smooth coating on the ends of the bones. Accumulated meniscus and cartilage damage is what turns an ACL injury into early arthritis years later. For active patients, the strongest argument for reconstruction is protecting those structures for the decades ahead.
How Dr. Gombera Diagnoses an ACL Tear
Diagnosis starts with your story and a hands-on exam, including the Lachman test, a gentle maneuver that measures how far the shinbone slides forward. An MRI confirms the tear and, just as important, checks the meniscus, cartilage, and the other ligaments. When more than one ligament is involved, the injury is planned differently; see multi-ligament knee injuries.
Treatment: What Happens First
The first steps are the same whether or not you eventually choose surgery: control swelling with rest, ice, compression, and elevation, then restore full motion and wake up the quadriceps in physical therapy. Surgeons call this prehab, and it measurably improves outcomes. If you choose reconstruction, surgery is typically scheduled a few weeks after injury, once the knee has calmed down. Return to sport after reconstruction takes approximately 6 to 9 months.
When to See a Doctor
Get evaluated promptly if you heard a pop and the knee swelled within hours, if the knee buckles or gives way, if you cannot bear weight, or if the knee is locked and will not straighten. Numbness, a cold foot, or a knee injured in a high-speed accident needs emergency care the same day.
Frequently Asked Question
Can a torn ACL heal on its own?
A complete ACL tear does not heal on its own. The ligament has a poor blood supply and its torn ends pull apart. Some partial tears, and some complete tears in lower-demand patients, can still do well without surgery if the knee stays stable through rehabilitation.
Do I need surgery if my knee feels stable?
Possibly not. If your knee does not give way during your normal activities and you do not play pivoting sports, structured physical therapy may be all you need. Dr. Gombera will tell you honestly which group you fall into.
What happens if I skip surgery and my knee keeps giving way?
Every giving-way episode can damage the meniscus and the cartilage surfaces. Over years, that accumulated damage raises the risk of early arthritis. Recurrent instability is the strongest reason to reconstruct an ACL.
How soon after an ACL tear is surgery done?
Usually a few weeks after the injury, once swelling settles and motion returns. Operating on a swollen, stiff knee increases the risk of stiffness afterward. That waiting period is used for prehab, which improves results.
When can I return to sports after ACL reconstruction?
Return to sport takes approximately 6 to 9 months. Clearance is based on testing, not just the calendar: strength and hop testing comparing the surgical leg to the healthy one must be passed first.
Can I walk on a torn ACL?
Often yes. Many people walk normally in a straight line within a week or two. That does not mean the knee is fine. The instability shows up with twisting, cutting, or uneven ground, which is exactly when new damage occurs.
Schedule an ACL Evaluation in Houston
Dr. Gombera evaluates ACL injuries at Texas Orthopedic Hospital (7401 Main St), the Memorial office (8731 Katy Freeway, Suite 110), and the Baytown office (7718 Garth Rd). Same-week consultations are available.

