Medically reviewed by Mufaddal M. Gombera, MD, Board-Certified Orthopedic Surgeon.
ACL reconstruction rebuilds a torn anterior cruciate ligament with a tendon graft so the knee stops giving way and the meniscus and cartilage are protected from further damage. Dr. Mufaddal Gombera is board-certified in orthopedic surgery with subspecialty certification in sports medicine. He served as an assistant team physician for Northwestern University football, the Chicago Cubs, and the Chicago Blackhawks during his time in Chicago, and he currently serves as a team physician for Texas Southern University. He applies that same return-to-play standard to every patient he reconstructs.
What Is ACL Reconstruction?
ACL reconstruction replaces a torn anterior cruciate ligament with a tendon graft, because a fully torn ACL cannot be reliably stitched back together. The graft is anchored in bone tunnels drilled in the thighbone and shinbone, where it heals into place and takes over the old ligament’s job: keeping the shinbone from sliding forward and controlling rotation. The surgery is performed arthroscopically, through small incisions, and fixes the problem that matters most after an ACL tear: a knee that gives way.
Graft Choice: Patellar Tendon, Hamstring, or Quadriceps
There is no universally best ACL graft; there is a best graft for you. The main options come from your own knee, and each carries a trade-off worth understanding in plain terms:
- Patellar tendon (bone-patellar tendon-bone). A center strip of the tendon below your kneecap, with a small block of bone on each end. The bone plugs heal solidly into the tunnels, and this graft has the longest track record in high-level athletes. The trade-off: more pain in the front of the knee afterward, especially with kneeling.
- Hamstring tendon. Tendons from the inner thigh, folded into a strong bundle. Less kneeling pain and a smaller incision. The trade-off: some lasting hamstring weakness, and soft tissue heals into bone tunnels more slowly than bone does.
- Quadriceps tendon. A thick, strong strip of tendon from above the kneecap. It offers substantial tissue with less kneeling pain than the patellar option, and its use has grown steadily in recent years.
- Donor tissue (allograft). Avoids any harvest from your leg, but re-tear rates run higher in young, high-demand athletes. It is generally reserved for older or lower-demand patients and for some revisions.
Dr. Gombera’s approach is individualized: your age, sport, position, kneeling and squatting demands, prior injuries, and anatomy all factor into the recommendation.
What Happens During Surgery
You receive anesthesia, and the whole procedure typically takes about 1.5 to 2 hours. Dr. Gombera harvests and prepares the graft, examines the entire joint with the arthroscope, and treats what he finds: a torn meniscus is repaired in the same sitting whenever the tissue quality allows. Tunnels are drilled in the thighbone and shinbone at the ACL’s anatomic attachment points, the graft is pulled through, and it is fixed with screws or buttons that hold it securely while it heals into the bone. Precise tunnel placement is the single most important technical detail in this operation; poorly placed tunnels are the leading technical reason reconstructions fail and need revision.
Discover Your Ortho Options
Recovery: Cleared by Testing, Not the Calendar
Return to sport takes approximately 6 to 9 months for an autograft (and 9 to 12 months for an allograft), but the date on the calendar is not what clears you. The graft needs time to mature, and your leg has to prove it is ready: quadriceps and hamstring strength testing, plus a series of single-leg hop tests, comparing the surgical leg against the healthy one. Athletes who return before meeting those benchmarks re-tear at meaningfully higher rates, so Dr. Gombera holds the line on criteria-based clearance even when the season is calling.
Risks, Stated Honestly
ACL reconstruction is a common and reliable procedure, and it still carries real risks: graft re-tear (highest in young athletes returning to pivoting sports), stiffness or loss of motion, kneeling pain with patellar tendon grafts, numb patches of skin near the incisions, and the rare but serious risks of infection and blood clots. When more than one ligament is injured, the operation and its risks change substantially; that situation is covered on our multi-ligament knee injuries.
Recovery Timeline
- Day of surgery: Outpatient surgery. Home the same day with a brace and crutches.
- Weeks 1 to 2: Swelling control, full knee extension, and quadriceps activation. Physical therapy starts within the first week.
- Weeks 2 to 6: Wean off crutches, restore full motion, stationary bike, and build a strength base.
- Months 2 to 4: Progressive strengthening. Running typically begins around month 3, once strength benchmarks are met.
- Months 4 to 9: Agility, cutting, and sport-specific training as strength returns.
- Approximately months 6 to 9: Return to sport after passing strength and hop testing that compares the surgical leg to the healthy one (later for allograft).
Every recovery is individualized. You will receive a written protocol, and Dr. Gombera’s team coordinates directly with your physical therapist, in Houston or at home.
Discover Your Ortho Options
When ACL Reconstruction Is Not the Right Answer
Honest patient selection matters as much as surgical technique. Lower-demand patients whose knees stay stable in daily life often do well with structured rehabilitation alone, and for them surgery adds risk without a clear benefit; see the candid discussion on our ACL tear. Children and adolescents with open growth plates need modified planning, because standard tunnel placement can injure the growing bona. And when significant arthritis is already present, reconstruction will not relieve the arthritis pain; Dr. Gombera will discuss arthritis-focused alternatives instead.
Discover Your Ortho Options
Frequently Asked Question
Which ACL graft is best?
There is no single best graft. Patellar tendon, hamstring, and quadriceps grafts each trade strengths for drawbacks, which is why Dr. Gombera matches the graft to your age, sport, kneeling demands, and anatomy rather than using one graft for everyone.
How long does ACL reconstruction surgery take?
Most ACL reconstructions take about 1.5 to 2 hours. It is outpatient surgery, and you go home the same day with a brace and crutches.
How soon after my injury will surgery be scheduled?
Typically a few weeks after the injury. Waiting until swelling settles and full motion returns lowers the risk of post-operative stiffness. That window is used for prehab, which improves final results.
Will my meniscus be treated during the same surgery?
Yes. Meniscus tears are common alongside ACL tears, and Dr. Gombera repairs the meniscus during the same procedure whenever the tissue allows. A repaired meniscus may slow the early rehab timeline slightly, and it is worth it.
When can I go back to my sport?
Return to sport takes approximately 6 to 9 months for an autograft, and longer (about 9 to 12 months) for a donor-tissue allograft. Clearance is earned by testing, not the calendar: quadriceps and hamstring strength plus hop testing must approach the healthy leg before Dr. Gombera clears cutting and pivoting.
What happens if my new ACL tears?
Graft re-tears are uncommon but real, and the risk is highest in young athletes who return to sport early. If a reconstruction fails, revision surgery is a distinct procedure with its own workup; see our revision ACL reconstruction.
Schedule an ACL Reconstruction Consultation in Houston
Dr. Gombera performs ACL reconstruction at Texas Orthopedic Hospital and sees patients at the Main St, Memorial (8731 Katy Freeway), and Baytown (7718 Garth Rd) offices. Same-week consultations are available.


