Medically reviewed by Mufaddal M. Gombera, MD, Board-Certified Orthopedic Surgeon.
Hip preservation surgery is the family of operations that fix a painful hip while keeping your own joint. Dr. Mufaddal Gombera has directed the Hip Preservation Center at Texas Orthopedic Hospital since 2015 and has performed more than 3,000 hip arthroscopies. Just as important, he runs the evaluation that determines which preservation procedure your hip actually needs, arthroscopic or open, and tells you honestly when preservation is not the answer.
What Hip Preservation Surgery Means
Hip preservation surgery corrects the structural problem causing your hip pain while keeping the joint you were born with. It stands in contrast to hip replacement, which removes the joint surfaces and implants a prosthesis. Preservation exists because implants wear with time and activity, a poor trade for young, active patients whose cartilage is still healthy. Fix the mechanics early, and many hips never need replacing. That principle is the founding mission of the Hip Preservation Center.
Preservation splits into two branches. The arthroscopic branch treats problems at the joint surfaces through quarter-inch incisions: hip arthroscopy for impingement, labral repair and reconstruction, and cartilage treatment. The open branch, this page’s focus, treats problems of bone alignment that no camera-based procedure can reach.
Arthroscopic vs Open: How the Decision Is Made
The shape and alignment of your bones decide the operation, not preference. Arthroscopy excels when the socket is well positioned but its surfaces are damaged: a torn labrum, an impinging cam bump, injured cartilage. Open preservation is required when the socket or femur itself is aimed wrong. The clearest example is dysplasia, a socket too shallow to cover the ball: you can repair the labrum arthroscopically, but the socket is still shallow, and the tear will return. The bone must be repositioned.
Dr. Gombera makes this call with standing X-rays and specific measurements of socket coverage and femoral shape, plus MRI to grade cartilage and 3D CT when planning demands it. Getting this decision right is the most important step in hip preservation; getting it wrong is a leading reason first surgeries fail and patients need revision evaluation.
The Open Preservation Procedures, Explained Simply
- Surgical hip dislocation. A controlled open approach that safely rotates the ball out of the socket, protecting its blood supply, so the entire joint can be seen and treated. It is reserved for complex shapes arthroscopy cannot fully reach, such as severe impingement and deformities like Perthes disease.
- Femoral osteotomy. Cutting and realigning the upper thigh bone when the femur itself points at the wrong angle, whether from developmental deformity, prior injury, or rotational problems. Realignment redistributes force across healthy cartilage.
These are significant operations with real recoveries, laid out honestly in the timeline on this page. They are also, for the right anatomy, the only procedures that address the true cause.
Discover Your Ortho Options
Who Needs Open Preservation Instead of a Scope
Patterns that point away from arthroscopy alone and toward open surgery include:
- Confirmed dysplasia on standing X-rays, especially with a labral tear driven by socket overload
- Borderline dysplasia in flexible patients, where judgment and measurements matter enormously
- Severe or complex deformity from Perthes disease, slipped capital femoral epiphysis, or prior fracture
- Femoral rotation or angle problems producing pain and impingement that a scope cannot correct
- Selected patients with early-stage osteonecrosis, where joint-preserving options are weighed case by case
How the Hip Preservation Center Directs Your Care
One evaluation, every option on the table. Dr. The Center’s team model exists so your diagnosis, not a single surgeon’s toolkit, determines your operation. Referring physicians receive findings and the plan after every consultation.
Risks, Stated Honestly
Open preservation procedures carry more recovery and more risk than arthroscopy, and pretending otherwise serves no one. Risks include infection, blood clots, nerve irritation, delayed bone healing after osteotomy, hardware discomfort that occasionally requires screw removal, and the possibility that arthritis progresses despite a well-executed correction. The counterweight: for correctly selected patients, these operations relieve pain and materially extend the life of the natural hip. Selection is the safeguard.
When Hip Preservation Surgery Is Not the Right Answer
Preservation only makes sense when there is a healthy joint left to preserve. Once arthritis is advanced, with clear joint space loss on standing X-rays, no osteotomy or arthroscopy can bring the cartilage back, and pursuing preservation anyway trades real recovery time for predictable disappointment. For those hips, the honest conversation is hip arthroscopy vs hip replacement, and Dr. Gombera will have it with you directly, including referral to a trusted replacement surgeon. Severe osteonecrosis with collapse of the femoral head and certain inflammatory joint diseases also fall outside preservation. If a previous preservation attempt has failed, start with revision hip arthroscopy.
Frequently Asked Question
What counts as hip preservation surgery?
They share one goal, relieving pain and protecting cartilage so replacement is delayed or never needed.
How do you decide between arthroscopy and open surgery?
The bone problem decides. Impingement and labral tears live at the joint surfaces and suit arthroscopy. Dysplasia and rotational deformities are alignment problems of the whole socket or femur, and no keyhole procedure can move a socket; they need osteotomy. Standing X-rays with specific measurements make the call, which is why the evaluation matters more than any preference.
Am I too old for hip preservation?
Age matters less than cartilage. Preservation candidates are typically adolescents through patients in their 40s, but the real gatekeeper is joint health on imaging: healthy cartilage and a correctable structural problem. A 50-year-old with excellent joint space may still be a candidate, while advanced arthritis at any age points to replacement instead.
Does insurance cover hip preservation surgery?
Medically indicated preservation procedures, arthroscopy and osteotomy alike, are covered by most major plans after conservative care is documented. Our team verifies your benefits before scheduling and explains any out-of-network or bundled options. See our insurance information page, and ask the office about specifics for your plan.
Find Out Which Preservation Procedure Your Hip Needs
One evaluation at the Hip Preservation Center, Texas Orthopedic Hospital (7401 Main St, Houston), maps your anatomy and directs you to the right procedure. Consultations are also available at the Memorial office (8731 Katy Freeway, Suite 110) and in Baytown (7718 Garth Rd).


