Dr. Gombera’s Blog

What’s the Difference Between a Sprained and a Broken Ankle?

A sprained ankle happens when the ligaments around the joint are stretched or torn. A broken ankle means one or more bones are fractured, causing sharp pain.

Medically reviewed by Mufaddal M. Gombera, MD · July 15, 2025

3 min read

When your ankle suddenly twists or takes a hard hit, it can leave you feeling unsure about what just happened. Is it a small injury that will heal on its own, or something more serious that needs medical care right away? It’s often hard to tell the difference between a sprain and a break, since both can cause pain, swelling, and trouble walking. This kind of confusion is common, but it’s important to understand what’s really going on inside your ankle. Knowing the difference will help you protect your ability to move and make sure you recover fully and confidently.

What Is an Ankle Sprain?

An ankle sprain happens when the ligaments, strong bands that connect the ankle bones, are stretched or torn. This usually occurs when you twist, roll, or turn your foot in an unusual way, forcing the ankle to move beyond its normal range and injuring the ligaments.

What Is a Broken Ankle?

A broken ankle means that one or more of the bones in the ankle joint are cracked or broken, usually from a fall, twist, or direct hit. Common signs include sudden and strong pain, swelling, bruising, tenderness, changes in the shape of the ankle, and trouble or inability to stand or walk.

Sprained Vs Broken Ankle

The following are the main differences between ankle sprains and fractures:

  • Location of Pain: Sprains usually cause pain around the soft tissue areas near the joint where the ligaments are located, while a broken bone causes pain directly over the bone itself.
  • Sounds at the Time of Injury: A sprain might cause a popping sound when the ligament stretches or tears, while a fracture often makes a cracking or snapping noise when the bone breaks.
  • Visible Signs: Both sprains and fractures can lead to swelling and bruising, but in most cases, only fractures cause obvious changes like the ankle looking out of place or deformed.
  • Ability to Put Weight on the Ankle: People with a sprained ankle might still be able to walk or stand, although it may hurt, while those with a broken ankle usually can’t put any weight on it at all.
  • Numbness or Tingling: Feeling numbness or tingling is more common with broken bones because nerves can be affected by the injury, or swelling can press on nearby nerves.

Treatment Difference Between a Sprained and Broken Ankle

The treatment for a sprained ankle and a broken ankle is different because the injuries are not the same. Both may start with basic care like rest, ice, compression, and elevation to ease pain and swelling. However, sprains usually heal with support from a brace and physical therapy to strengthen the ankle. A broken ankle, on the other hand, often needs a cast or walking boot to keep the bones in place, and in some cases, surgery is needed to fix and stabilize the broken bones. Healing from a break usually takes longer and needs more rehab than a sprain. Getting the right diagnosis is very important to make sure the injury is treated properly and to prevent problems later.

Wrapping Up

Ankle injuries are way too common. However, when you experience one, it can be hard to tell whether it’s a sprain or a fracture. Identifying the earlier-mentioned differences between a sprained and a broken ankle can help you get timely treatment.

If you have a sports injury, visit our board-certified, fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon at Mufaddal Gombera, MD, for treatment. Our doctor specializes in sports medicine. Call us at (713) 794-3457 to book an appointment.

Dr. Mufaddal Gombera

Written & medically reviewed by Mufaddal M. Gombera, MD
Dual board-certified orthopedic surgeon · Director, Hip Preservation Center at Texas Orthopedic Hospital.

What our patients are saying

Trusted by patients. Respected by athletes.

See why patients trust Dr. Gombera for expert orthopedic and sports medicine care, from injury treatment to recovery.

  • Google
  • healthgrades.
  • vitals
  • facebook
Always has a smile on his face, extensive knowledge in orthopedics and a conservative approach to treatment. Would highly recommend.
Anthony Sakr
Excellent Doctor, he treats you very well and all the studies are done quickly. Right now I am seeing him for various diseases and I can recommend him 100%.
Leticia Alanis
Dr. Gombera provided the information I needed to have peace of mind in my ACL reconstruction recovery. Also gave me a path forward for when to become concerned if there’s no progress. I felt pretty confident about my journey thanks to him.
Ishar Rosado Irizarry
Very prompt. Friendly and informative. Every person I interacted with was concerned that I was treated promptly and escorted me to the next office. Dr G was encouraging and in explaining my progress and future goals.
Leona Chaffee
Finally I found a Doctor that knew what he was doing! My knee was a mess from a previous surgery and a complete ACL tear. Dr. Gombera fixed me up. I received top notch care from his team. I wish I had gone to him first!! If you’re in need of any kind of Ortho surgery, Dr. Gombera is your man!!!
katherine king
Doctor was very thorough in explaining my knee conditions. It never once felt like he was in a hurry to leave the room. Instead, he gave me several treatment options and took his time answering my questions and concerns.
Clarissa Torres
Dr. Gombera and his team are Excellent! The hospital treatment for our overnight stay was 5star! I would recommend him! Thank you for all you did for my daughter!
Soed Mail
Always has a smile on his face, extensive knowledge in orthopedics and a conservative approach to treatment. Would highly recommend.
Anthony Sakr
Excellent Doctor, he treats you very well and all the studies are done quickly. Right now I am seeing him for various diseases and I can recommend him 100%.
Leticia Alanis
Dr. Gombera provided the information I needed to have peace of mind in my ACL reconstruction recovery. Also gave me a path forward for when to become concerned if there’s no progress. I felt pretty confident about my journey thanks to him.
Ishar Rosado Irizarry
Very prompt. Friendly and informative. Every person I interacted with was concerned that I was treated promptly and escorted me to the next office. Dr G was encouraging and in explaining my progress and future goals.
Leona Chaffee
Finally I found a Doctor that knew what he was doing! My knee was a mess from a previous surgery and a complete ACL tear. Dr. Gombera fixed me up. I received top notch care from his team. I wish I had gone to him first!! If you’re in need of any kind of Ortho surgery, Dr. Gombera is your man!!!
katherine king
Doctor was very thorough in explaining my knee conditions. It never once felt like he was in a hurry to leave the room. Instead, he gave me several treatment options and took his time answering my questions and concerns.
Clarissa Torres
Dr. Gombera and his team are Excellent! The hospital treatment for our overnight stay was 5star! I would recommend him! Thank you for all you did for my daughter!
Soed Mail
Dr Mufaddal Gombera is an excellent doctor, very professional and knowledgeable in his specialty. He gave me confidence to know that I am in good hands. I’m confident on his diagnosis. He really cares about the patient’s recovery.
Maricela Higareda
Dr. Gombera is truly an answer to many prayers. I struggled with intense pain that eventually made it very difficult for me to walk and work as a Physical Therapist. I knew of Dr. Gombera’s work from treating his patients and seeing their outcomes, so I was already very confident in his level of care. My expectations were far exceeded. From the first visit, to surgery, and recovery after has been handled with such care and compassion. On to my knee now!!! #ankylosingspondywarrior!
Summer Medlin
I am so glad I was referred to Dr. Gombera. His entire team took excellent care of me. Not only was I given ample time to discuss all my concerns with him, but he did an incredible job repairing my shoulder. I would recommend him a thousand times over.
Sarah Novak
I appreciate everything that Dr. Gombera and his staff has done for me through my journey of recovery. I’m doing so much better I still have a little ways to go but I’m moving around well. I’m going back to work next week. Thanks Dr. Gombera for helping me.
Victoria Haywood
Dr Gombera is an amazing, caring, compassionate and very knowledgeable orthopedic physician. I continue to be his patient because of his integrity and knowledge. No hesitation in recommending Dr Gombera…5 Star rating is well earned on his part.
Cindi Brake
Dr Gombera’s office is professional and very helpful. They are prompt to answer questions and guide his patients through their processes. They are patient and truly care about you and work hard in getting you the best care possible. My shoulder surgery went smoothly and recovery was much better than expected! Total success from beginning to the end!
Mistelle Robinson
Dr Gombera was very attentive to my concerns and trying to find solutions. Felt very comfortable with his plan and insights with my possible hip issues.
Jill Ganse
Dr Mufaddal Gombera is an excellent doctor, very professional and knowledgeable in his specialty. He gave me confidence to know that I am in good hands. I’m confident on his diagnosis. He really cares about the patient’s recovery.
Maricela Higareda
Dr. Gombera is truly an answer to many prayers. I struggled with intense pain that eventually made it very difficult for me to walk and work as a Physical Therapist. I knew of Dr. Gombera’s work from treating his patients and seeing their outcomes, so I was already very confident in his level of care. My expectations were far exceeded. From the first visit, to surgery, and recovery after has been handled with such care and compassion. On to my knee now!!! #ankylosingspondywarrior!
Summer Medlin
I am so glad I was referred to Dr. Gombera. His entire team took excellent care of me. Not only was I given ample time to discuss all my concerns with him, but he did an incredible job repairing my shoulder. I would recommend him a thousand times over.
Sarah Novak
I appreciate everything that Dr. Gombera and his staff has done for me through my journey of recovery. I’m doing so much better I still have a little ways to go but I’m moving around well. I’m going back to work next week. Thanks Dr. Gombera for helping me.
Victoria Haywood
Dr Gombera is an amazing, caring, compassionate and very knowledgeable orthopedic physician. I continue to be his patient because of his integrity and knowledge. No hesitation in recommending Dr Gombera…5 Star rating is well earned on his part.
Cindi Brake
Dr Gombera’s office is professional and very helpful. They are prompt to answer questions and guide his patients through their processes. They are patient and truly care about you and work hard in getting you the best care possible. My shoulder surgery went smoothly and recovery was much better than expected! Total success from beginning to the end!
Mistelle Robinson
Dr Gombera was very attentive to my concerns and trying to find solutions. Felt very comfortable with his plan and insights with my possible hip issues.
Jill Ganse

Book your appointment today

Returning Athletes To An Active & Fulfilling Lifestyle

If you have suffered from a sports injury or an orthopedic issue that is keeping you from doing the things you enjoy, it’s time to book an appointment with Dr. Mufaddal Gombera. Call (713) 794-3457.